Now that the big night is fast approaching - June 10th - and the nominees for the 61st Annual Antoinette Perry "Tony" Awards have been announced, it's time to speculate as to who will be taking home statuettes this year!
I'll go through each of the 25 categories one by one, predicting the winner and musing a bit on those most deserving or overlooked.
Best ChoreographyRob Ashford,
CurtainsMatthew Bourne & Stephen Mear,
Mary Poppins*Bill T. Jones,
Spring AwakeningJerry Mitchell,
Legally Blonde The MusicalTo me, it seems likely that, despite a relatively competitive year for choreography, the inventive choreography of Bill T. Jones will take home the Tony this year. Though I was very much impressed by the tremendously energetic choreography for
Legally Blonde and by some of the inventive dances in
Mary Poppins, I thought that Jones's choreography for
Spring Awakening did the best job of adding an extra layer to the show, especially the sensual choreography for "Touch Me" and the spastic dance moves for "Totally F****d."
Best OrchestrationsBruce Coughlin,
Grey Gardens*Duncan Sheik,
Spring AwakeningJonathan Tunick,
LoveMusikJonathan Tunick,
110 in the Shade
While Jonathan Tunick is renowned in the Broadway community for his consistent excellence as an orchestrator, this year I think that the voters will acknowledge the work of Duncan Sheik, who managed to meld computerized music with the use of a live band to create a fresh sound for
Spring Awakening. While many lament the downsizing of Broadway orchestras in favor of computer-enhanced orchestrations, in this case, the use of computer enhancement adds palpably to the effect of the music. I'm surprised not to see Mary-Mitchell Campbell's orchestrations for
Company among those in the running for this award. Despite the fact that I missed the brassiness of the orchestrations on the original Broadway cast recording, orchestrating a John Doyle-directed show is no easy task. Jonathan Tunick (for
LoveMusik) and Campbell tied for the Drama Desk Awards, so I suppose Tunick still has a chance, but I think it's likely that the Tony voters will have a different view of the orchestration race than the Drama Desk.
Best Book of a MusicalRupert Holmes & Peter Stone,
Curtains*Doug Wright,
Grey GardensHeather Hach,
Legally Blonde The MusicalSteven Sater,
Spring AwakeningI was terribly surprised when Rupert Holmes and Peter Stone won the Drama Desk for
Curtains. I thought that the book for
Curtains was perhaps one of the most trite and unfunny (especially for a comedy) that I'd ever come across. Any of the other nominees would, to me, be preferable, but I think that Doug Wright still has a chance at the Tony Award. Wright's book is lovely and subtle, underscoring brilliantly the blurring of the line between the past and the present. Steven Sater still has a shot as well. His book for
Spring Awakening captures the feel of 1890s Germany evocatively without losing sight of the updated quality that this modern adaptation employs.
Best ScoreFred Ebb, John Kander & Rupert Holmes,
CurtainsScott Frankel and Michael Korie,
Grey GardensLaurence O'Keefe and Nell Benjamin,
Legally Blonde The Musical*Duncan Sheik and Steven Sater,
Spring Awakeningdata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8da48/8da48cd1adad0c28a2a06b52d374062c90347338" alt=""
This award, hands down, will go to
Spring Awakening. Despite the sentimantality toward Kander & Ebb's score for
Curtains, particularly since Fred Ebb died just a few years ago, rewarding a score of this lackluster quality would be criminal. There will still be at least one or two more new Kander & Ebb musicals on Broadway, so I figure the Tony voters figure they'll still have another shot to reward Ebb posthumously. In the meantime,
Spring Awakening's score, while perhaps lyrically imperfect, does a perfect job of upholding the production's conceit that, once the musical's 1890s German characters pull their microphones out of their school jackets, they're rock stars, able to express the angsty emotions they've kept pent up inside. The lovely pastiche score for
Grey Gardens is also notable, but not to the degree that
Spring Awakening's is.
Best Scenic Design (Play)*Bob Crowley & Scott Pask,
The Coast of UtopiaJonathan Fensom,
Journey's EndDavid Gallo,
Radio GolfTi Green and Melly Still,
Coram BoyWhile I liked very much David Gallo's set for
Radio Golf, which, besides for being extraordinarily naturalistic, also placed the play's campaign office setting in context within the overall Hill District setting of the play, the voters will likely reward Crowley & Pask for their work on the epic
The Coast of Utopia. These design awards are often the most appropriate outlets to reward the more overblown shows on Broadway (they say it's best artistically not to leave humming the sets, and sometimes that's just what you end up doing). Whatever I have to say about the quality of
The Coast of Utopia as a play, Lincoln Center Theater certainly devoted a lot of attention to the intricacies of their production, and it showed stunningly.
Best Scenic Design (Musical)*Bob Crowley,
Mary PoppinsChristine Jones,
Spring AwakeningAnna Louizos,
High FidelityAllen Moyer,
Grey Gardens
It's likely that Crowley will win for the whimsy and efficiency of his sets for
Mary Poppins. I suppose there's a chance that voters will recognize the sparse but highly effective set for
Spring Awakening, heavily researched by designer Christine Jones and utilizing on-stage audience seating, but it seems like a long shot.
Best Costume Design (Play)Ti Green and Melly Still,
Coram BoyJane Greenwood,
Heartbreak HouseSanto Loquasto,
Inherit the Wind*Catherine Zuber,
The Coast of UtopiaThis is another category where spectacle is sure to win out.
The Coast of Utopia was a jaw-droppingly large production for Lincoln Center Theater this past season, and its costumes were no exception. The shear number of costumes alone -- 450 -- is insane! And they are quite attractive.
Best Costume Design (Musical)Gregg Barnes,
Legally Blonde The Musical*Bob Crowley,
Mary PoppinsSusan Hilferty,
Spring AwakeningWilliam Ivey Long,
Grey Gardens
My guess is that Bob Crowley may be taking home several awards on Tony night. His costumes for
Mary Poppins are the best bet for a win in this category. It's one of the shows most reliant on splashy costumes, and Crowley's were particularly effective for
Poppins. William Ivey Long may also have a shot at the award; his costumes for
Grey Gardens were handsome and effective.
Best Special Theatrical Event*Jay Johnson: The Two and OnlyKiki & Herb Alive on BroadwayI'm not familiar with
Kiki & Herb, but
The Two and Only was a charming, earnest little show. I went into it thinking, Oh, God, not a show with a ventriloquist, but I was very much pleasantly surprised. Johnson has winning personality and considerable talent. I'm not really sure who will win, but neither of these were particularly noteworthy in the 2006-2007 season.
Best Lighting Design (Play)Paule Constable,
Coram BoyBrian MacDevitt,
Inherit the Wind*Brian MacDevitt, Kenneth Posner and Natasha Katz,
The Coast of UtopiaJason Taylor,
Journey's EndAnother win for
The Coast of Utopia, I suspect. What more is there to say -- the production was spectacular.
Best Lighting Design (Musical)
*Kevin Adams,
Spring AwakeningChristopher Akerlind,
110 in the ShadeHoward Harrison,
Mary PoppinsPeter Kaczorowski,
Grey Gardens
Kevin Adams is sure to win this award. His inventive use of neon lighting (most effective when viewed from the mezzanine) absolutely enhanced
Spring Awakening's already potent brand of theatrical magic. What, for me, constitutes what is considered the "best" in design categories is the success of a design element's integration into the whole of the theatrical experience at hand. If anyone else has a shot, it's Christopher Akerlind, who masterfully lit the gigantic sun onstage at Studio 54 during
110 in the Shade.
Best Direction (Play)Michael Grandage,
Froxt/NixonDavid Grindley,
Journey's End*Jack O'Brien,
The Coast of UtopiaMelly Still,
Coram BoyThe Coast of Utopia. Tired of hearing that title? So am I. But it takes a strong director to make a good case for a bloated, overblown play like
The Coast of Utopia, and Jack O'Brien, a Broadway veteran, was that man. Perhaps Grandage or Grindley have a chance, but I suspect that O'Brien will be rewarded for taking on such a massive undertaking.
Best Direction (Musical)
John Doyle,
CompanyScott Ellis,
CurtainsMichael Greif,
Grey Gardens*Michael Mayer,
Spring AwakeningMichael Mayer looks to be the frontrunner in the Best Director race. His guidance helped a vibrant young cast and inspired creative team put on one hell of a show. Ellis and Greif are longshots, but Doyle, whose inventive Sondheim stagings are all the rage nowadays, may have a chance at the statue for his actor-musician staging of
Company.
Best Featured Actor (Play)
Anthony Chisholm,
Radio Golf*Billy Crudup,
The Coast of UtopiaEthan Hawke,
The Coast of UtopiaJohn Earl Jelks,
Radio GolfStark Sands,
Journey's EndThis is one category that seems like a wide open playing field. Chisholm and Jelks were both standouts in
Radio Golf, and Crudup (and Hawke, to a lesser degree) were adequate in
The Coast of Utopia. Sands was also quite effective in
Journey's End. My guess is that Crudup will take home the award, but I think Chisholm and Stark Sands also have a palpable chance. This is an award I'm looking forward to.
Best Featured Actress (Play)*Jennifer Ehle,
The Coast of UtopiaXanthe Elbrick,
Coram BoyDana Ivey,
ButleyJan Maxwell,
Coram BoyMartha Plimpton,
The Coast of UtopiaThough Martha Plimpton took home this award at the Drama Desk Awards (Ehle wasn't nominated), I think that Jennifer Ehle will probably take home the Tony. I'm not familiar with the work of Elbrick, Ivey, or Maxwell, but Ehle was one of the best things about
Utopia. I wish she had had a more prominent role throughout the trilogy, but as Natalie Herzen in
Shipwreck, she more than proved her acting chops. It was one of the most thrilling performances I saw all year.
Best Featured Actor (Musical)Brooks Ashmanskas,
Martin Short: Fame Becomes MeChristian Borle,
Legally Blonde The MusicalJohn Cullum,
110 in the Shade*John Gallagher, Jr.,
Spring AwakeningDavid Pittu,
LoveMusikIn order to reward, in some form, the talents of the young cast of
Spring Awakening, I think it will be Gallagher who takes home this award. He's excellent as Moritz, the misfit character, and has excellent comic timing. Borle was winning in
Blonde, as was Cullum in
110.
Best Featured Actress (Musical)Charlotte d'Amboise,
A Chorus LineRebecca Luker,
Mary PoppinsOrfeh,
Legally Blonde The Musical*Mary Louise Wilson,
Grey GardensKaren Ziemba,
Curtains
Mary Louise Wilson was probably the most favorably reviewed among these nominees; she's excellent as Big Edie in the second act of
Grey Gardens, just as formidable as Christine Ebersole, who plays her daughter. I guess Ziemba also has a shot, but Wilson looks to be the clear frontrunner.
Best Actor (Play)Boyd Gaines,
Journey's End*Frank Langella,
Frost/NixonBrian F. O'Byrne,
The Coast of UtopiaChristopher Plummer,
Inherit the WindLiev Schreiber,
Talk RadioHere is one of the most competitive categories. All five of these actors got very favorable reviews for their performances. It will likely be Frank Langella, who, despite very little physical resemblance to President Nixon, manages to be absolutely believable in
Frost/Nixon. Schreiber also seems like a likely winner, but I'd really like to see Boyd Gaines, who gave a stunningly subdued performance in Journey's End take home this award. Both Langella and Gaines (who was, for the Drama Desk Awards, placed in the featured category) took home Drama Desk Awards last Sunday.
Best Actress (Play)*Eve Best,
A Moon for the MisbegottenSwoosie Kurtz,
Heartbreak HouseAngela Lansbury,
DeuceVanessa Redgrave,
The Year of Magical ThinkingJulie White,
The Little Dog LaughedThis has to be one of the hardest categories to predict. Kurtz is unlikely to win, but the other four all have a good shot. White gave a brilliant comic performance in
The Little Dog Laughed, and Lansbury and Redgrave both reminded audiences of their "legend" statuses. Eve Best, in her first New York role, however, may just take home this award for her brilliant performance as Josie in
A Moon for the Misbegotten. Though she doesn't meet the character's brutish character description requirements, her absolute commitment to the role really shone through. This one is hard to predict, but my money is ever so slightly on Best to best the rest. If I got what I wanted, it would probably be Lansbury.
Best Actor (Musical)Michael Cerveris,
LoveMusik*Raul Esparza,
CompanyJonathan Groff,
Spring AwakeningGavin Lee,
Mary PoppinsDavid Hyde Pierce,
Curtains
Esparza is the frontrunner in this category. He's brilliant in
Company and long overdue for some Broadway recognition. Cerveris and Pierce may be possible winners, but it's most likely that Esparza will finally take home a Tony. Though his piano-playing is minimal in
Company, he really allows an audience to tap into his vulerability. Plus, his singing is superb.
Best Actress (Musical)Laura Bell Bundy,
Legally Blonde The Musical*Christine Ebersole,
Grey GardensAudra McDonald,
110 in the ShadeDebra Monk,
CurtainsDonna Murphy,
LoveMusik There was Tony buzz surrounding Christine Ebersole this time last year, around the time when she was in
Grey Gardens off-Broadway at Playwrights Horizons. She's brilliant as Big Edie in the first act and Little Edie in the second act, and it seems almost certain that she'll take home her second Tony (the first was for 42nd Street). I think that Audra McDonald still has a fighting chance in the Best Actress category. She and Donna Murphy tied at the Drama Desk Awards (Ebersole won last year when
Grey Gardens was off-Broadway and was therefore ineligible this time around), so there's a possibility of a shake-up, particularly since
Grey Gardens opened so long ago, but Ebersole still seems to be the name on everybody's lips, so we'll have to wait to find out. Everyone in the category, however, is strong.
Best Play RevivalInherit the Wind*Journey's EndTalk RadioTranslations Journey's End was this season's little play that couldn't. I had no idea what it would be about before I saw it. The playwright and director (and most of the cast) are all unknown, and it's a depressing-looking play about World War I.
Journey's End has had a consistently hard time attaining an audience (most weeks, it played to 30% or less capacity), but I think it will be recognized for its superb quality come Tony night (which happens to fall on the same night as its closing performance). Boyd Gaines, Hugh Dancy, and Stark Sands, head a cast that is uniformly excellent, and the design elements all came together to present a stunningly powerful production. That reminds me that I've been thinking recently about how egregious it is that there's no category for Best Sound Design. Sound is an integral element to a great Broadway production, and
Journey's End was a stunning example of what a great sound designer, in this case Gregory Clarke, can do.
Best Musical RevivalThe Apple TreeA Chorus Line*Company110 in the ShadeThis one's probably going to John Doyle's inventive staging of
Company. I found the overall production to be quite cold and distancing and the actor-musicianship to be inferior to that on display in last season's
Sweeney Todd, but
Company has favorable reviews and Raul Esparza going for it. With a flimsy book that barely holds up after 37 years, it's a wonder Doyle could salvage
Company as well as he could.
110 in the Shade also has a shot, I think, but reviewers (and perhaps Tony voters) found the show a bit too quaint, with the star turn from its leading actress Audra McDonald the major standout of the production.
Best Play*The Coast of UtopiaFrost/Nixon The Little Dog LaughedRadio GolfWhen Tom Stoppard set out to write
The Coast of Utopia, he was obviously feeling grandiose. He set out to write a play about Russian history and ended up with an 8-hour epic. The play is one huge demonstration of what happens when you're too vainglorious to subject yourself to a sensible regiment of good old-fashioned editing. There is no major story arc, and the play feels like a bloated, obscure history lesson. Nonetheless, it was a hit with critics and audiences alike, most of whom probably felt proud that they were able to sit upright for that long in a theatre. Whatever I found at fault in regards to playwright, however, was at least in part redeemed by a beautiful, well-executed production headed by Jack O'Brien. My pick would be for
Radio Golf, the final play in August Wilson's 10-play cycle chronicling African-American life in the United States, but critics found the play to be less engaging than others in the cycle.
Best MusicalCurtainsGrey GardensMary Poppins*Spring Awakening
There was talk early on in speculation over the Tony race this year that
Legally Blonde was going to give
Spring Awakening a run for its money. Good out-of-town reviews and appeal to venues that host national tours across the country would have given
Legally Blonde a huge leg up, but perhaps the nominators sensed the possibility of an upset and purposefully excluded
Blonde.
Spring Awakening will almost certainly take home top honors for its revolutionary Broadway production. If it doesn't, it'll be one of the biggest crimes in Tony history (I'd also be satified if
Grey Gardens won, but that seems unlikely). I'm surprised by the amount of people who feel that
Curtains still has a shot at the award, but
Curtains and
Poppins have the advantage of being more family-oriented shows with splashy productions that would be more popular for tour audiences (it's the tour producers who ultimately seem to have the greatest hand in these things). I hope Tony voters stick to their artistic guns and reward the show that's truly the best,
Spring Awakening, which would also likely do good business in a national tour.